Old Fashioned Crunchy

$ 4.99
This product is SOLD OUT.
16 oz      $ 4.99
Add to cart
Sold Out

Old Fashioned Crunchy is a great tasting, all-natural peanut butter made with our special blend of perfectly roasted peanuts and just a tiny bit of salt – that’s it. Old Fashioned Crunchy is perfect for the peanut purist that desires a little crunch in their life and is a great addition to recipes. We also suggest grabbing a spoon and eating it straight from the jar!

If the natural peanut oil starts to separate, just stir it back in. To help prevent the oil from separating, we recommend that you store the jar upside-down in your pantry or place in the refrigerator—although refrigeration is not necessary.  Be sure to store in a cool, dry place.


  • 8g protein per serving
  • No added sugar
  • Non-GMO Project Verified
  • Vegan Action Certified
  • Gluten Free
  • Kosher
  • No partially hydrogenated oils
  • 0g trans fat per serving
  • No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives

See nutrition information for total fat and saturated fat content

Non-GMOgluten freevegankosher 


Peanuts, salt

What's in the Jar


Non-GMO gluten free vegan kosher

See nutrition facts

Customer Reviews

Based on 21 reviews

Thanks, for resending the peanut butter to my sister. She is in heaven. You Rock!!

My favorite natural peanut butter

Crunchy and no added sugar or oils! This is my favorite natural peanut butter. I buy it in bulk and really wish they offered larger jars. It feels very wasteful with the tiny jars they use.

Also I'm not sure if they changed something recently, but it no longer seems to separate much when I receive it which is great. I originally got worried they started adding palm oil since I've never seen a natural peanut butter stay stable like this, but the ingredients still just show peanuts and salt.

Accidentally bought this instead of Crunch Time

We've been eating Crunch Time for awhile now and really enjoying it. I accidentally bought the Old Fashioned yesterday and didn't realize it. First, I've eaten a lot of natural peanut butters, and I've never seen one that separated to this extreme. Second, I found it very bland. My bad for not buying Crunch Time, but I buy it locally and didn't realize there were options other than crunchy and smooth. It might be very good if you like extremely plain peanut butter. In its favor, it does have a lot of crunch, once you get it all stirred together.

The Best

This is the tastiest peanut butter. Have been eating it for years.

Your Cart
Your cart is empty