Old Fashioned Smooth

Regular price$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Title

Old Fashioned Smooth is a natural, creamy peanut butter from Peanut Butter & Co, made with just two ingredients: USA-grown roasted peanuts and a pinch of salt — no artificial colors or flavors and no preservatives. It has a traditional, purely-peanut flavor and 8g of protein per serving. Non-GMO Project Verified, Vegan, Kosher, Gluten Free. If you're searching for a natural peanut butter with the fewest possible ingredients, Old Fashioned Smooth is one of our simplest options.

For a simple snack, spread it on a halved banana or a slice of whole-grain toast. For something unexpected, stir a spoonful into mashed sweet potatoes for a creamy, savory-sweet side dish. It also stirs beautifully into hot oatmeal.

Because there's no added oil, natural oil separation may occur. Here's a fun fact: oil separating from peanut butter has a scientific name, syneresis, which just means a liquid separating from a solid. It happens because there's nothing in the jar but peanuts and salt, so the oil rises on its own. Keep your jar in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to keep natural peanut butter tasting fresh. Here are some tips for managing oil separation:

  1. When you open the jar for the first time, stir the oil back in as completely as possible. This first stir is the most important.
  2. If you eat peanut butter frequently and don't mind a little stir now and then, you can just keep it in a cool cupboard.
  3. If you don't want to stir anymore, try keeping your stirred peanut butter in the refrigerator. The colder temperature will slow the oil separation, but the peanut butter will be firmer, so you might need to let it come to room temperature before using it.
  4. Some people like storing their stirred jars upside down to encourage the oil to migrate to the bottom. If you try that, make sure the lid is on really tight and place a folded paper towel under the jar in case any oil leaks out.
  5. Some people pour off all of the oil and eat only what's left. The oil is high in fat but also high in flavor, and removing it will make the peanut butter much less spreadable, so keep that in mind before making any rash decisions.
  • Free Shipping Orders Over $49
  • Made in the USA

Find the Best Smooth and Creamy Peanut Butter for You

Product Name

# of Ingredients

Sweetness Level

Prep Style

Texture

Roast

Smooth Operator

4

Lightly Sweetened

No-Stir

Super creamy

Medium

Simply Smooth

3

No added sugar

No-Stir

Super creamy

Medium

Old Fashioned Smooth

2

No added sugar

Stir & Spread

Creamy but a little coarse

Medium Dark

Farmer & Friends Smooth

1

No added sugar

Stir & Spread

Coarse grind

Dark & Rich