How Subscriptions Work at Peanut Butter & Co

Love peanut butter as much as we do? Our subscription program makes it easier than ever to keep your pantry stocked with your favorite Peanut Butter & Co. products – automatically, on your schedule, and with built‑in savings. Powered by Shopify and managed through Recharge, our subscription service is designed to be flexible, convenient, and completely in your control. 

Set It and Forget It

When you visit any eligible product page, you’ll see an option to “Subscribe & Save.” Just select your preferred delivery frequency—every 2 month, every 2 months, or whatever works best for you. Add items to your cart as usual, check out, and your subscription is ready to go. From there, we’ll take care of everything: preparing your order, billing on schedule, and shipping your favorites right to your door.

Total Flexibility

Life changes, and your subscription can, too. Through your Recharge customer portal, you can easily adjust your delivery schedule, swap flavors, skip a shipment, pause your subscription, or cancel altogether—anytime, with no fees or commitments. Need that jar of Crunch Time sooner? Move up your next order in just a click. Traveling or need a break? Push back the date or skip a cycle.

Easy Account Access

After your first subscription purchase, you’ll receive an email with a link to set up your account. From your dashboard, you’ll have full visibility into upcoming deliveries, past orders, payment info, and any customizations you want to make. It’s simple, intuitive, and built to save you both time and effort.  If you already have an account, you can login here: https://ilovepeanutbutter.com/account

Stay Stocked & Save

Subscribers enjoy exclusive savings on every recurring order—no promo codes needed. Just delicious peanut butter delivered automatically, exactly when you want it.

If you have any questions, our team is always here to help. Happy snacking!