Old Fashioned Smooth

$ 4.13
This product is SOLD OUT.
Buy 1 $ 4.49 each 0% off
Buy 6 $ 4.27 each 5% off
Buy 12 $ 4.13 each 8% off
Add to cart
Sold Out      

Old Fashioned Smooth is a great tasting, all-natural peanut butter made with our special blend of perfectly roasted peanuts and just a tiny bit of salt – that’s it. Old Fashioned Smooth is perfect for the peanut purist and is a great addition to recipes. We also suggest grabbing a spoon and eating it straight from the jar!

If the natural peanut oil starts to separate, just stir it back in. To help prevent the oil from separating, we recommend that you store the jar upside-down in your pantry or place in the refrigerator—although refrigeration is not necessary.  Be sure to store in a cool, dry place.


  • 8g protein per serving
  • No added sugar
  • Non-GMO Project Verified
  • Vegan Action Certified
  • Gluten Free
  • Kosher
  • No partially hydrogenated oils
  • 0g trans fat per serving
  • No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives

See nutrition information for total fat and saturated fat content

Non-GMOgluten freevegankosher 


Peanuts, salt

What's in the Jar


Non-GMO gluten free vegan kosher

See nutrition facts

Customer Reviews

Based on 20 reviews
Jarful was gone in no time!

Best tasting peanut butter I have ever had. I had it on toast, on fresh apples, spooned out of the jar and even mixed it a known brand of chocolate syrup.

Liquid Peanut Butter

Ordered multiple jars of peanut butter. Other varieties arrived fine. The Old Fashioned Smooth showed up in a complete liquid state. You could’ve drank it thru a straw. I contacted the company and they corrected the issue in a very timely manner. We’ve never had any issues prior to this with their products. Strange!

Love this peanut butter

I live in England and, for a while now, have been unable to find my favourite “Old Fashioned Smooth” peanut butter here. So I was thrilled to bits to discover I could buy it from the US company that makes it. So on my last 2 visits to stay with my son and family in New Jersey I’ve made sure that I’ve ordered a couple of jars each time to bring back home with me.
Please Peanut Butter & Co do NOT stop making this particular version of your peanut butters!

Peanuts, salt and tons of stirring

I love that the ingredients are clean, just peanuts and salt. Tastes great! I would love, love, love to find the same only without stirring. I like the smooth texture of no stir better but it’s full of junk. Until I find one that is good ingredients and smooth, I’ll be buying this one. Thanks so much!

Your Cart
Your cart is empty