Contact Us


We love to get letters, so please write to us! Our mailing address is:
Peanut Butter & Co.
P.O. Box 2000
New York, NY 10101
If you are writing with a question about a product you've purchased at a grocery store or specialty food shop, please include all of the following:


  • The "Eat By" date and Time Code on the top of the jar, near the lid
  • The name and address of the store where purchased the product
  • The date you purchased the product


For Mail Order Customer Service and other product inquiries, please send an email to:
customer.service AT ilovepeanutbutter DOT com
To place an order by phone, or to speak to a customer service representative, please call 1-866-ILOVEPB (1-866-456-8372).
Please note that our Customer Service desk is open from Monday-Friday, 10AM to 4PM, EST.
Our Sandwich Shop is located at 240 Sullivan Street, New York, NY 10012.  The shop's telephone number is (212) 677-3995. You can call them to find out about catering, private parties, and to check holiday hours.
If you are a journalist or a member of the press and are interested in writing or producing a story about Peanut Butter & Co., please contact our Publicity Director, Adam Shapiro at:
adam.shapiro AT ilovepeanutbutter DOT com